Federal Reports

In March 2016, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) issued a Chilled Work Environment Letter for Watts Bar Nuclear Plant. The NRC concluded a chilled work environment existed in the Operations Department because of a perception that operators were not free to raise safety concerns using all available avenues without fear of retaliation. According to the NRC Policy Statement for Nuclear Employees Raising Safety Concerns Without Fear of Retaliation, "A reluctance on the part of employees to raise concerns is detrimental to nuclear safety." The Nuclear Oversight group, through the Quality Assurance (QA) function, should provide reasonable assurance that plant safety functions are performed in a satisfactory manner. Additionally, Nuclear Oversight's Employee Concerns Program (ECP) is charged with providing an independent avenue for employees to raise concerns. With these key roles, it is crucial that employees in Nuclear Oversight feel free to raise concerns without fear of retaliation. The OIG found the work environment for Nuclear Oversight is not always conducive to raising concerns without fear of retaliation. Most QA employees felt free to raise concerns or problems without fear of retaliation; however, one QA employee informed us that although they would report a nuclear quality problem or concern, they would not report these problems or concerns to their management. While most QA employees felt free to raise concerns or problems, most ECP employees did not without fear of retaliation. Our interviews with QA and ECP personnel identified issues that could be impacting employees' willingness to report concerns, including (1) distrust of management, (2) past concerns being overridden or ignored, (3) work being influenced, and (4) QA rotational positions.

This report contains classified information that is exempt from disclosure under the Freedom of Information Act. To obtain further information, please contact the OIG Office of Counsel at OIGCounsel@oig.treas.gov, (202) 927-0650, or by mail at Office of Treasury Inspector General, 1500 Pennsylvania Avenue, Washington DC 20220.